Peter Got it Right. Then Everything Went Wrong


Rev. Jason B. Elder

August 18, 2026

Peter Got it Right. Then Everything Went Wrong

↓

Like many of you, I've been spending a fair amount of time in the Gospel of Matthew. There's a lot I want to say about the structure and themes in that gospel (see the How Odd Section below for a slice of it), but there's one story that has captured my imagination. It's found in Matthew 16.

Jesus asks his biggest question in the strangest place possible.

Caesarea Philippi wasn't neutral ground at the time. It was actually the epicenter of pagan worship. It was a city built around a cave the ancient world believed was the literal gate to the underworld!

Furhter, locals threw sacrifices into that cave to appease the "god" Pan and Caesar had a marble temple there, stamped with his own claim to sonship.

That's where Jesus turns to his disciples and asks, "Who do people say that I am?"

Easy question. They rattle off the rumors, essentially saying, "People say you might the some kind of reincarnation of a great prophet."

Then Jesus asks the real question: "But who do you say that I am?"

In the Greek, the pronoun shift is glaring. This isn't a general survey. It's to each person in the group. Moment of truth.

Peter, standing in the shadow of that awful cave and in a city where the emperor claimed to be divine, says, "You are the Messiah, the Son of the Living God."

Jesus says Peter's answer is given from God. Good. Whew.

Then, six verses later, Peter, apparently delusionally high on getting the right answer, blows us. Wrongly confronts Jesus. NO ONE tells Jesus what to do! And Jesus pushes back. Hard.

Peter disagreed with Jesus' comment that he, Jesus, would go to Jersualem and suffer and die. Getting the confession right is one thing. Understanding that Christ will be who he wants to be and do what he wants to do is another.

How many times do we confess the right things and then protest how God chooses to work in our lives?

It's another amazing passage. I wrote a fuller commentary on this passage and walk through the passage in a bit more detail. You can read the full piece here.


The Liturgy Collection

At www.pastorjasonelder.com/liturgy you will find liturgies for all the liturgical seasons. Some of you have a running head start and you are working on Advent liturgies. Holy cow, I don't know how you do it!

I regularly add resources that have set up shop on my laptop over the years. I'm happy to share. Take a minute and say hi and how the liturgy helps. You can just reply to this email. I read and respond to each one.

Liturgy Corner

What I love about the liturgy this week is that it includes Psalm 124, a song of deliverance. That's so applicable to our lives and vocations. How many times have we seen people on the brink and then healing comes to them?

"We have escaped like a bird from the snare of the fowlers; the snare is broken, and we have escaped." Psalm 124:7

​Go to the liturgy​

Sounds Odd!

Did you know that Matthew organizes his gospel like the Torah?

Yep!

His audience is Jewish, so he structures it in five parts, mirroring the five books of Moses. Scholars sometimes call this "the five books of Matthew." Each section pairs a chunk of narrative with a chunk of teaching.

Here's what's cool: Matthew signals the transtion from one "book" to another with some version of the phrase, "when Jesus had finished saying these things."

Five hinges. Five books. One not-so-subtle message: Jesus is the new Moses and this is the new Torah.

  • Book 1: chapters 3-7 (Moses on the mountain, receves the law; Jesus' sermon on the mount, giving the new law: "You have heard it said . . . but I say unto you."
  • Book 2: chapters 8-10
  • Book 3: chapters 11-13
  • Book 4: chapters 14-18
  • Book 5: chapters 19-25

How fun! How odd!

A Benediction from Around the World

Today's benediction is from the Church of South India:

May God the Father bless you, God the Son heal you, God the Holy Spirit give you strength. May God the holy and undivided Trinity guard your bodies, save your souls, and bring you safe to His heavenly country.

All my best to you,

Rev. Jason B. Elder

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Jason's Odd Newsletter

I'm a writer and pastor, sharing reflections, prayers, and liturgies for anyone seeking a deeper, kinder faith. My work reaches readers in 160+ countries.

Read more from Jason's Odd Newsletter

Rev. Jason B. Elder November 17, 2026 Same Sermon, Two Rooms Every pastor has probably heard it, either at the door or the parking lot: "Pastor, that sermon was too political." This Sunday I am continuing my sermon series with, "What Do We Mean When We Say that Sermon is too Political?" In 2015 I was serving a Presbyterian Church in Southern California. Most of that congregation was first- and second generation Korean. One Sunday I preached on immigration: (Love the alien as yourself:...

Rev. Jason B. Elder August 18, 2026 The Back Porch Light Our oldest is at a local college. He goes to school full time and works 3 or 4 evenings a week. Recently I realized that when I go to the den, I go, almost instinctively to the back door, and turn on the light. With Daylights Savings, it's darker than usual, and the glow seems all the more important. I want the light to communicate something to him. We thought of you. We want you to be able to find your way up the steps and through the...

Rev. Jason B. Elder August 18, 2026 The Silence Between the Names Every year on All Saints Sunday, we read the names. Our Associate Pastor stands in the pulpit and reads the names. An elder will be in the balcony, ready to strike the church bell. A name is spoken and I carry a rose and place it in the hands of a congregant. Silence. Name. Bell. Rose. It's not efficient, but it is effective. The silence between names is long enough to hear a pew creak, a purse to unsnap for a tissue, a child...